These medications work slowly — they are not a quick fix.

One of the most frustrating symptoms men experience as they get older is having to get up multiple times at night to pass urine. Many men also notice urgency during the day, a slow stream, or the feeling that the bladder never quite empties.

These symptoms are very commonly related to benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) — an enlarged prostate.

In this newsletter, I want to explain one specific group of medications that may be recommended for some men: 5-alpha reductase inhibitors. These medications can actually shrink the prostate over time and may improve urinary symptoms for the right patients.

Why Does an Enlarged Prostate Cause Urinary Problems?

As men age, prostate cells gradually multiply, particularly in the central part of the prostate that surrounds the urethra (the tube urine flows through). As this area enlarges, it compresses the urethra and makes it harder for urine to pass.

This can lead to:

  • Slow or weak urine flow

  • Hesitancy (difficulty starting)

  • Feeling of incomplete emptying

  • Urinary frequency and urgency

  • Getting up at night to urinate (nocturia)

Over time, the bladder has to work harder to push urine past the prostate. This can make the bladder thicker and less elastic, which worsens urgency and frequency symptoms.

DO YOU HAVE A QUESTION?
Dr Chabert will be hosting a Q&A on THURSDAY 22ND JANUARY 7:30pm AEST on his YouTube channel, covering everything you need to know about prostate health, treatments, surgery, recovery & more!
Become a premium subscriber - Don’t miss your chance to be heard.

What Is a 5-Alpha Reductase Inhibitor?

Testosterone, the main male hormone, is converted in the prostate into a more active form called DHT (dihydrotestosterone). DHT plays a key role in prostate growth.

5-alpha reductase inhibitors block this conversion, which can:

  • Reduce DHT levels in the prostate

  • Gradually shrink the prostate

  • Improve urinary symptoms over time

Common examples include:

  • Finasteride

  • Dutasteride

Both medications work in a very similar way and are widely used in Australia and internationally.

Who Benefits Most From These Medications?

These medications are not for everyone, but they tend to work best for men who:

  • Have a larger prostate (usually >40cc)

  • Have a raised PSA (above ~1.4)

  • Are older (typically over 65–70 years)

  • Have significant urinary symptoms

  • Prefer medical therapy rather than surgery

Research shows that men with larger prostates do better when a 5-alpha reductase inhibitor is combined with an alpha-blocker (a medication that relaxes the prostate muscle to improve flow).

In Australia, there is a combination tablet available on the PBS, which makes this approach affordable and convenient for many men.

What Results Can You Expect?

These medications work slowly — they are not a quick fix.

Over 6 months or more, men can expect:

  • A 20–30% reduction in prostate size

  • Gradual improvement in urinary symptoms

  • A reduced risk of acute urinary retention (sudden inability to pass urine)

Studies show that these medications can reduce the risk of urinary retention by about 50%, although the absolute risk reduction is modest.

An Important Note About PSA Testing

If you take a 5-alpha reductase inhibitor for more than 6 months:

  • Your PSA level will drop by about 50%

  • To get your true PSA, the result needs to be doubled

This is very important for prostate cancer monitoring. Always make sure your doctor knows you are taking this medication when interpreting PSA results.

Are There Side Effects?

Like all medications, 5-alpha reductase inhibitors can have side effects. The most important to be aware of are:

  • Reduced libido (sex drive)

  • Changes in erectile function

  • Occasionally, mild mood changes

Because of these potential effects, I generally do not prescribe these medications to younger, sexually active men. They are best suited to older men, particularly those who are no longer sexually active or for whom sexual side effects are not a concern.

Is Medication Always the Best Option?

Not necessarily.

Some men prefer:

  • Minimally invasive treatments (e.g. UroLift, Rezūm)

  • Definitive surgical treatments (e.g. Green Light laser prostate surgery)

Choosing the right treatment depends on:

  • Prostate size

  • Symptom severity

  • PSA level

  • Bladder function

  • Personal preferences and lifestyle

This is why an individualised discussion with your urologist is so important.

In Summary

A 5-alpha reductase inhibitor may be suitable if:

  • Your prostate is enlarged

  • Your PSA is raised

  • You have significant urinary symptoms

  • You are older and not concerned about sexual side effects

  • You prefer medical management over procedures or surgery

As always, treatment should be tailored to you, not just your prostate size or test results.

Keep Reading